Plum Tomato
Born in an Amish farming community in Wisconsin during the 1870s, this remarkable paste tomato produces some of the largest sauce fruits you'll ever grow. Each oxheart-shaped beauty weighs 6 to 8 ounces with dense, meaty flesh that's surprisingly sweeter than typical paste varieties. These indeterminate vines stretch 3 to 8 feet tall across zones 2-11, delivering their prized harvest in about 80 days from transplant.

Photo © True Leaf Market(https://www.trueleafmarket.com/products/organic-amish-paste-tomato-seeds)
18-24 inches apart
Full Sun
Moderate
?-?
96in H x ?in W
Annual
High
Hover over chart points for details
Amish Paste stands apart as one of the ultimate dual-purpose tomatoes, combining massive size with exceptional sweetness in the paste category. These giants tip the scales at 6-8 ounces each, making them some of the largest paste tomatoes available, yet their rich flavor makes them equally delicious for fresh eating. The dense, meaty flesh cooks down into incredibly flavorful sauces while the juicy texture creates naturally thin bases perfect for customizing. Many seed savers consider this the holy grail of paste tomatoes, earning its place in Slow Food USA's Ark of Taste as a variety worth preserving.
These versatile giants excel in the kitchen whether you're making sauce, canning for winter, or slicing fresh for the table. The dense, meaty flesh breaks down beautifully for pasta sauces, though its naturally juicy texture creates thinner sauces that can be cooked down to your preferred consistency. Many gardeners love halving these beauties for roasting, where they caramelize into sweet, concentrated flavor bombs perfect for soups, pizzas, or eating straight from the oven. The exceptional sweetness that sets Amish Paste apart from other paste varieties makes it equally satisfying for fresh eating and sandwich slicing.
Start seeds indoors 6-8 weeks before your last spring frost date, sowing 1/4 inch deep in well-draining seed starting mix. Maintain soil temperature between 75-85°F for optimal germination, which typically occurs in 5-7 days. Use a heat mat if necessary and keep soil consistently moist but not soggy during the germination period.
Transplant seedlings outdoors after all danger of frost has passed and soil temperatures remain consistently above 60°F. Harden off plants gradually over 7-10 days before transplanting. Bury stems deeply to encourage adventitious root development, spacing plants 24 inches apart in rows 36 inches wide.
Harvest when fruits turn fully red with no green remaining on the shoulders, typically around 80 days from transplant. Gently twist ripe tomatoes off the vine or cut the stem with pruners to avoid damaging the plant. Since this indeterminate variety produces continuously, check plants regularly and harvest promptly to encourage continued fruit set. The harvest season can extend 2-4 months depending on your growing zone and frost dates.
As indeterminate plants, Amish Paste tomatoes benefit from regular pruning throughout the season. Remove suckers that develop in the crotch between main stems and branches to focus energy on fruit production. Strip lower leaves that become shaded or touch the ground, as these drain nutrients without contributing to harvest. Continue removing lower leaves progressively as plants grow to improve air circulation and reduce disease pressure.
Enter your ZIP code to see a personalized growing calendar for this plant.
“This treasured heirloom traces its roots back to the 1870s within an Amish farming community in Wisconsin. The variety emerged from the careful selection practices of Amish gardeners who valued both productivity and flavor in their food preservation efforts. Over generations, this tomato became a cornerstone of their agricultural tradition, prized for its exceptional paste-making qualities and reliability. The variety's journey from those Wisconsin farmsteads to gardens across America represents the enduring legacy of community-based seed saving and the Amish commitment to preserving superior food varieties.”