New York 12 is a crisphead lettuce that earned its reputation the hard way: by winning All-America Selections in 1963 and proving itself indispensable to gardeners ever since. Developed by Cornell University in the 1960s, this butter head cultivar combines tender, delicious leaves with remarkable resilience to heat, poor soils, and the bolting that defeats so many summer lettuce crops. Ready to harvest in 50 to 55 days, it grows as a compact mound reaching 5 to 10 inches tall, thriving across hardiness zones 2 through 10 with full sun and minimal fussing.

Photo © True Leaf Market
8
Full Sun
—
2-10
10in H x ?in W
—
Moderate
Hover over chart points for details
New York 12 looks as good as it tastes, with buttery tender leaves that perform equally well in the garden and on the plate. Its real strength lies in stress tolerance: it resists bolting even during hot spells and shrugs off poor soil conditions that would stress tender varieties. The 1963 All-America Selections award recognized what gardeners still appreciate today: a lettuce that actually delivers when conditions aren't perfect.
New York 12 shines in fresh salads, where its tender, buttery leaves provide a pleasant textural contrast to crispier greens. The compact heads are substantial enough for slicing into wedges for composed salads or serving whole as a base for warm bacon vinaigrette. Its ability to hold quality through the growing season makes it reliable for successive plantings throughout spring and into summer, when most lettuces bolt.
No timeline data available yet for this variety.
Start seeds indoors 4 to 6 weeks before your last spring frost, sowing them in trays or small pots at a soil temperature of 60 to 70 degrees Fahrenheit. Keep soil consistently moist and provide bright light once seedlings emerge.
Transplant seedlings outdoors after hardening off for 7 to 10 days, timing the move for when daytime temperatures reach the 50s and nights stay above freezing. Space plants 8 inches apart in rows 15 inches apart. New York 12's frost tolerance allows earlier transplanting than many tender lettuces.
Direct sow seeds outdoors as soon as soil can be worked in spring, pressing them lightly into moist soil surface or covering with no more than 1/4 inch of soil. Sow again in late summer for a fall crop in most zones.
Begin harvesting outer leaves once plants are 4 to 6 inches tall, or wait 50 to 55 days from planting for full mature heads. Cut the entire head at soil level using a sharp knife, or harvest individual outer leaves from the bottom up and allow the center to continue growing. Harvest in early morning when leaves are crisp and full of moisture for the best texture and flavor. New York 12's tendency to resist bolting extends the harvest window compared to other summer lettuces, allowing you to pick over a longer period.
Enter your ZIP code to see a personalized growing calendar for this plant.
“New York 12 emerged from Cornell University's breeding program in the early 1960s, developed specifically to solve a problem that plagued home and market gardeners alike: lettuce that would bolt or wilt under summer heat and stress. The variety debuted to immediate acclaim, earning the 1963 All-America Selections vegetable award for its proven tolerance to the environmental challenges that cause most lettuces to fail. This award recognized not just a good lettuce, but one with the durability to succeed where others faltered. From that moment, New York 12 became a standard for gardeners who wanted reliability without sacrificing quality.”