Old German Tomato is a heritage beefsteak that carries the legacy of the Mennonite community into modern gardens. This indeterminate variety produces enormous 1 to 2 pound fruits with a striking golden-yellow skin blushed with red stripes, ready to harvest in 70 to 79 days from transplant. Growing 48 to 72 inches tall in zones 2 through 11, it thrives in full sun with moderate water and rewards patient gardeners with meaty slices of exceptional flavor and remarkably few seeds. The fruits are oblate in shape and notably low in acid compared to traditional red tomatoes, making them a standout choice for fresh slicing and specialty preparations like yellow ketchup.

Photo © True Leaf Market
24
Full Sun
Moderate
2-11
72in H x ?in W
—
High
Hover over chart points for details
These massive bi-colored tomatoes can grow larger than dinner plates, reaching 2 pounds at their peak and delivering a flavor that's more intensely tomatoey than other yellow varieties due to a slightly higher acid content that paradoxically extends shelf life. The fruit's golden-yellow coloring with deep red striping creates a stunning visual presence on the vine and in the kitchen. True to its Mennonite heritage, this variety has been preserved and treasured for generations specifically because of its meaty texture, excellent flavor, and the surprisingly low seed count that makes it exceptional for slicing.
Old German Tomato excels as a slicing tomato for fresh eating, where its low acid content, meaty texture, and few seeds make it superior to traditional red varieties for the table. The golden-yellow flesh with red striping provides visual appeal to salads, sandwiches, and grain bowls. Its slightly higher acid content compared to other yellow tomatoes contributes to better shelf life and makes it remarkably suited for cooking applications, particularly for making yellow ketchup and other preserved tomato products. The abundance of juice and flesh per fruit, with minimal seed cavities, means less waste and maximum yield of usable tomato matter.
No timeline data available yet for this variety.
Start seeds indoors 6 to 8 weeks before your last spring frost, sowing them in a warm seed-starting mix. Maintain soil temperatures between 70 and 90 degrees Fahrenheit for reliable germination. Keep seedlings under grow lights and maintain warmth for strong development before transplanting.
Transplant seedlings outdoors after the last frost date when soil has warmed to at least 55 degrees Fahrenheit. Space plants 24 inches apart in rows 36 inches apart. True Leaf Market notes this variety thrives in garden plots, raised beds, and greenhouses, so choose the location that offers full sun and stable growing conditions.
Harvest Old German Tomatoes when they are fully ripe, with the golden-yellow color fully developed and the fruit yielding slightly to gentle pressure. The fruits should feel substantial and heavy for their size, indicating full juice content and flavor development. Pick tomatoes in the morning when temperatures are cool. According to Territorial Seed Company guidance, do not refrigerate freshly harvested ripe fruit to preserve the best flavor. If you have green fruit at season's end, ripen them in a cool, dark area, ensuring the fruits do not touch one another to prevent rotting.
As an indeterminate variety, Old German Tomato will benefit from selective pruning to improve air circulation and fruit quality. Remove suckers (shoots that grow between the main stem and branches) to direct energy into fruit production and prevent dense canopy growth that can trap moisture. Pruning lower leaves once the plant is established can reduce disease pressure near the soil line. However, avoid excessive pruning that would remove foliage needed to shade developing fruit in extremely hot climates.
Enter your ZIP code to see a personalized growing calendar for this plant.
“Old German Tomato emerged from the Mennonite community, a heritage variety passed down through generations of careful cultivation and seed saving. The Mennonites, known for their agricultural expertise and commitment to preserving heirloom varieties, developed and maintained this tomato as a cornerstone of their food culture. Its journey from family gardens in Mennonite settlements to contemporary seed catalogs represents a deliberate effort to preserve open-pollinated, non-GMO varieties that honor both flavor and cultural tradition. Today, seed companies like True Leaf Market and MIgardener continue this legacy by offering organic, non-GMO seeds to gardeners seeking authentic heirloom genetics.”